Retired Lt. Col. Jamie Gottschling supervised Wes Moore for every day of the governor's six-month deployment to Afghanistan in 2005 and 2006. He rated Moore a "top 1% officer" on his official evaluation. And he is now publicly stating that Moore lied about leading soldiers in combat.
Moore's response was to suggest Gottschling is mentally ill.
In a podcast interview with Chuck Todd, the Maryland governor offered this when asked about his commanding officer's accusations: "I pray for him and his family. I know mental health and the challenges people go through are real." That's not a denial. That's not a rebuttal with evidence. That's a sitting governor implying the man who supervised him in a war zone has lost his mind.
Gottschling wasn't having it. "It's such a crazy accusation," he told the Washington Free Beacon. "It seems like he's indicating I have some kind of mental illness or personality problem. I don't know where that came from."
Here's what Gottschling does know, because he was there. Moore served as an information operations officer with the 82nd Airborne Division's 1st Brigade. He coordinated information ops. He worked directly under Gottschling. "It's disingenuous to say he led soldiers into combat or did direct action activities in combat zones," Gottschling said. When asked point blank whether Moore's characterization constitutes stolen valor, the retired lieutenant colonel answered: "Yeah, I believe it is."
Gottschling's officer evaluation of Moore contains no indication that the future governor ever came under fire. No known Army documents exist corroborating Moore's claim that he led soldiers in direct combat. Photos from a March 1, 2006, end-of-tour award ceremony show Moore receiving an Army Commendation Medal — a lower-tier medal mutually exclusive with the Bronze Star Moore later claimed on his 2006 White House fellowship application.
That Bronze Star claim has its own odor. Moore listed it on the fellowship application before he'd actually received the medal. He didn't get the actual Bronze Star until almost two decades later, after a California senator intervened. When Comedy Central introduced him as a Bronze Star recipient, Moore said "yes." When the New York Times and FOX45 pressed him on it, he called it "an honest mistake" made "nearly 20 years ago."
Moore also tried to produce a witness. He pointed to retired First Lt. Anthony Del Signore, an ex-Marine who served alongside him, claiming Del Signore's account "debunks" the reporting. But when the Free Beacon contacted Del Signore directly, the retired Marine said only that he was once part of a convoy with Moore that took fire from an Afghan mountainside. He would not corroborate Moore's central claim — that he led soldiers in combat. The witness Moore hand-picked couldn't back up the one thing Moore needed him to say.
Moore tried one more angle on Gottschling: dismissing him as politically motivated. "He's come home and he's now become a MAGA supporter and a MAGA donor," Moore said. Gottschling addressed that too. He told reporters he refused to support Moore's gubernatorial campaign, telling the governor directly: "I flat out said no. I can't support you in the campaign because we can't be more different in our beliefs." Then he added: "This is uncomfortable for me, but it's the truth and it's about doing what's right."
The pattern fits a template that veterans recognize instantly. The claim gets bigger with every retelling. The deployment becomes combat. The desk job becomes leading men under fire. And when the people who were actually there start talking, the story doesn't hold. "He wanted to emotionalize and aggrandize his activities," Gottschling said. "It just wasn't true."
Moore told combat stories for two decades. His commanding officer says they're fabricated. His handpicked corroborating witness won't corroborate. His Bronze Star was listed on an application before it existed. And when confronted with all of it, the governor of Maryland looked into a podcast microphone and said he prays for the mental health of the man calling him a liar.
Gottschling spent his career evaluating officers. He rated Moore a top 1% officer. He just won't call him an honest one.
