Judge Rules NYT May Have Made It All Up — And Now Trump's $15 Billion Suit Moves Forward

Judge Rules NYT May Have Made It All Up — And Now Trump's $15 Billion Suit Moves Forward

Fifteen billion dollars. That's the number sitting on the New York Times's desk this morning after U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday — a George H.W. Bush appointee sitting in Tampa, Florida — ruled that President Trump "plausibly alleged" that two of the paper's own reporters lacked adequate support for claims they published accusing him of committing complex tax crimes.

The suit moves forward. Discovery is coming.

The case centers on "Lucky Loser," a 2024 book by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, published by Penguin Random House. The book didn't just question Trump's business acumen or suggest he played aggressive tax strategy — it accused the sitting president of the United States of criminal conduct. Specific, complex tax crimes. The kind of accusation that, if you're going to print it, you'd better have the receipts.

Judge Merryday looked at the evidence and concluded Trump had plausibly shown they didn't.

Now, the ruling wasn't a clean sweep. Two related claims involving newspaper articles were dismissed — one co-authored by Buettner and Craig, another by Peter Baker, the Times's chief White House correspondent. But the core of the suit — the book-length accusation of criminal tax fraud published by the nation's most influential newspaper and one of the world's largest publishing houses — survives. That's the piece that matters. That's where the $15 billion lives.

Consider what discovery means in a case like this. Internal emails between editors and reporters. Draft manuscripts with margin notes. Source communications. The editorial process that turned whatever Buettner and Craig actually had into a published accusation of felony conduct against a former and future president. All of it potentially on the table.

The Times has spent decades wrapping itself in the First Amendment like a security blanket every time someone questions its reporting. And the First Amendment does protect a free press — aggressively, as it should. But it has never protected fabrication. It has never shielded a newsroom that publishes criminal accusations it cannot support. The standard for defamation of a public figure is actual malice — knowledge that a statement is false, or reckless disregard for whether it's true. Judge Merryday just ruled that Trump's complaint clears that bar well enough to proceed to trial.

Imagine, for one moment, if Fox News had published a book in 2016 accusing Barack Obama of committing complex tax crimes without adequate sourcing. Picture the media reaction. The congressional hearings. The journalism school symposiums. The Pulitzer board would have issued a statement by lunchtime. When it's the Times doing it to Trump, the story barely cracks the front page.

Penguin Random House is in this too. They didn't just distribute the book — they published it, which means their legal team presumably reviewed the manuscript before it hit shelves. Whatever due diligence process cleared a book accusing a president of tax fraud is now subject to examination. The publishing giant gets to explain what, exactly, they verified before putting their name on it.

The Times will appeal. They'll invoke press freedom. They'll frame this as a threat to journalism itself. But the judge who made this call wasn't appointed by Trump. He was put on the bench by George H.W. Bush. And his ruling doesn't say the Times is guilty — it says Trump's claim that they published unsupported accusations of criminal conduct is plausible enough to deserve a trial.

Fifteen billion dollars. Two reporters. One book. And a courtroom in Tampa where the paper of record now has to show its work.


Most Popular


Most Popular


You Might Also Like:

Trump Sat Between Xi and Putin and Told Them Both to Cut Their Nukes

At approximately 3 a.m. Eastern Time on November 19th, Donald Trump walked into a government-owned lakeside resort calle

Bennie Thompson Asked the FBI to Name a Right-Wing Terrorist Group. The FBI Named Antifa Instead.

FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia sat in front of the House Homeland Security Committee on November 18th, fielding qu

Texas Imam Called for Enemies to Be 'Killed One by One' — CNN Missed It

On November 13, inside the North Austin Muslim Community Center at 11900 N. Lamar Blvd in Austin, Texas, a prayer servic

Gas Prices Dropped 57 Cents in a Month — Right After You Voted

On September 25, the national average for a gallon of gas was $4.49. By October 25, it was $4.25. By November 9 — three
`; } } div_section.html(htmlDisplayInner); } } }, error: function (xhr, status, error) { div_section.html(''); } }); }); } } jQuery(document).ready(function($){ adglareAdsCallCommon(633389817, 9, 'middleAdsArtical'); adglareAdsCallCommon(715703577, 8, 'titleAdsArticle'); adglareAdsCallCommon(492993975, 7, 'headerTopAdZone'); adglareAdsCallCommon(516806821, 6, 'righttopAdZone'); adglareAdsCallCommon(496248318, 3, 'sidebarAds'); adglareAdsCallCommon(700725431, 5, 'sponserAds'); adglareAdsCallCommon(459258633, 4, 'articalAdZone'); adglareAdsCallCommon(775969945, 2, 'footerTextAdZone'); adglareAdsCallCommon(950202339, 1, 'footerAdZone'); }); jQuery(document).ready(function($){ var survey_id = $('.survey-id').text(); if(survey_id != ''){ $('.iframe-content').load("https://www.americanpolling.org/survey/"+survey_id+"/survey2stats.html"); } var contact_id = $('.contact-id').text(); var list_id = $('.list-id').text(); if(contact_id != ''){ $('#frame').attr('src', 'https://americanpolling.org/survey/test_excite.php?contact_id='+contact_id+'&list_id='+list_id); } });