Tesfaye Cooper walked out of Stateville Correctional Center in November 2025. By April 2026 — five months later — he was attacking a bicyclist in a Chicago subway station and stealing the man's bike.
Cooper is one of four people who kidnapped a mentally disabled 18-year-old white teenager in January 2017, held him for days in a Chicago apartment, bound and gagged him, sliced his scalp with a knife, and livestreamed the whole thing on Facebook.
You probably remember the video. Most of the country saw it. Four attackers taunting a bound, terrified kid while the camera rolled. The footage was so grotesque that even cable news — which will air almost anything — struggled with how much to show. It was a hate crime by every definition of the term, committed on camera, broadcast to the world in real time.
For that, Cooper got seven years. Jordan Hill got eight. Tanishia Covington, who was 24 at the time, got three. And Brittany Covington — who participated in the kidnapping and torture of a disabled teenager on a Facebook livestream watched by millions — received probation.
Probation.
Tanishia Covington was out on parole by June 2018 — roughly a year and a half after she helped hold a kid captive and carve into his scalp on camera. When Cook County Judge William Hooks sentenced her, she offered this in court: "I'm sorry to everyone for my participation, being childish."
Judge Hooks wasn't buying it. "We have one of the victims and his family here," he said. "'Everyone' is nebulous."
Childish. That was the word she chose. Not monstrous. Not evil. Childish — like she'd been caught sneaking out past curfew instead of torturing a disabled teenager for sport.
Hill, for his part, told the judge, "I'm proud to be black." His juvenile record already included armed robbery, residential burglary, and vehicle theft. He was paroled in October 2023, re-incarcerated for a parole violation by December 2024, and is currently locked up with a new release date of April 2027. Tanishia Covington's prior record included attempted armed robbery and aggravated assault — charges that were dropped.
These weren't first-time offenders who snapped. These were people with violent histories who escalated to something unspeakable, got sentences that amounted to a bureaucratic shrug, and cycled right back into the system.
Cooper only mumbled his apology to the victim in court. The victim's family made what was described as an "unprecedented" request — not for a harsher sentence, but for extra help and social services for their son. They watched their disabled child get tortured on a livestream and asked the court for help, not vengeance.
The court gave Cooper seven years. The state let him out. He lasted five months.
The Daily Wire's Luke Rosiak reported on Cooper's return to custody. CWB Chicago was the only outlet that covered the April 2026 arrest at all. The same national media apparatus that couldn't stop replaying the livestream footage in 2017 had nothing to say when one of the perpetrators proved, on schedule, that the sentence didn't work.
Four people tortured a disabled kid on camera. One got probation. One was out in eighteen months. One has been in and out on parole violations. And the one who served the closest thing to a real sentence was back in custody five months after release for attacking a stranger in a subway station.
The family asked for help. The system offered a revolving door.
